Join the 80,000 other DTN customers who enjoy the fastest, most reliable data available. There is no better value than DTN!

(Move your cursor to this area to pause scrolling)




"Previously I was using *******. IQFeed is WAY more economical, and for my charting needs is just as good, if not better." - Comment from Public Forum Post
"If you want customer service that answers the phone, your best bet is IQFeed. I cannot stop praising them or their technical support. They are always there for you, and they are quick. I have used ****** too but the best value is IQFeed." - Comment from Public Forum
"I would just like to say that IQFeed version 4 is running very well and I am very happy with its performance. I would also like to extend a big thanks for the fast and efficient help that I always receive. My questions and concerns are always addressed promptly. Way to go!" - Comment from Josh in CO.
"The service is great, I see a noticeable improvement in my volume profiles over [broker]'s data feed" - Comment from Larry
"Very impressed with the quality of your feed - ******* is a real donkey in comparison." - Comment from A.C. via Email
"I have been using IQFeed now for a few years in MultiCharts and I have zero complaints. Very, very rare to have any data hiccups or anything at all go wrong." - Comment from Public Forum
"Its working FABULOUSLY for me!! Holy cow...there has been so much I've been missing lately, and with this feed and Linnsoft software...I'm in the game now." - Comment from Chris R.
"You have an excellent feed. Very few spikes for Spot Forex." - Comment from Public Forum Post
"I just wanted to let u know that your data feed/service is by far the best!!! Your unfiltered tick data is excellent for reading order flow and none of your competitors delivers this quality of data!" - Comment from Peter via Email
"I will tell others who want to go into trading that DTN ProphetX is an invaluable tool, I don't think anyone can trade without it..." - Comment from Luther
Home  Search  Register  Login  Recent Posts
Information on DTN's Industries:
DTN Oil & Gas | DTN Trading | DTN Agriculture | DTN Weather
Follow DTNMarkets on Twitter
DTN.IQ/IQFeed on Twitter
DTN News and Analysis on Twitter
Viewing User Profile for: ElliottAnalysis
About Contact
Joined: Mar 29, 2023 10:31 PM
Last Post: Apr 8, 2023 01:03 AM
Last Visit: Apr 8, 2023 01:03 AM
Website:  
Location:
Occupation:
Interests:
AIM:
ICQ:
MSN IM:
Yahoo IM:
Post Statistics
ElliottAnalysis has contributed to 3 posts out of 21191 total posts (0.01%) in 402 days (0.01 posts per day).

20 Most recent posts:
New IQFeed Forum » Unaligned Bars from BW Command Apr 8, 2023 01:03 AM (Total replies: 9)

Thanks Gary for your insight.

Just to give you some more information about our requirement: we are trying to write data to a csv file which is supposed to be current all the time. Based on your above explanation, I assume that we should take the last bar of the first BW response as 'not closed' and if we receive any subsequent bar with the same timestamp, we should update the last bar. It seems all fine and we can easily implement this logic. However, Example 2 in the original post has some more issues that we cannot resolve with the above logic. The biggest issue is that the bars are not 3 minutes apart uniformly -- some are 2 minutes apart. Furthermore, the update message are not received for the last bar only but comes for a few bars further back as well. Please let us know how the investigation goes.

New IQFeed Forum » Unaligned Bars from BW Command Apr 4, 2023 11:52 AM (Total replies: 9)

Thanks Gary for the answer.

I am using the following command (requested at 12:39:xx, where I don't know the seconds for the requested time):

BW,@ES#,180,20230404 093900,,,,,B-@ES#-00180-s,s,'',30

Once again, I got the following output:

B-@ES#-00180-s,BH,@ES#,2023-04-04 12:24:00,4116.25,4120.75,4116.25,4120.75,943647,11233,0,
B-@ES#-00180-s,BH,@ES#,2023-04-04 12:27:00,4120.75,4125.25,4120.25,4124.75,955352,11679,0,
B-@ES#-00180-s,BH,@ES#,2023-04-04 12:30:00,4125.00,4126.00,4124.25,4126.00,961787,6435,0,
B-@ES#-00180-s,BH,@ES#,2023-04-04 12:33:00,4126.00,4128.00,4125.50,4126.25,969806,8019,0,
B-@ES#-00180-s,BH,@ES#,2023-04-04 12:36:00,4126.25,4126.75,4123.75,4124.00,977011,7005,0,
B-@ES#-00180-s,BH,@ES#,2023-04-04 12:39:00,4124.00,4125.00,4121.50,4123.00,986272,8861,0,
B-@ES#-00180-s,BH,@ES#,2023-04-04 12:42:00,4123.00,4124.00,4122.75,4123.50,987705,1433,0,
B-@ES#-00180-s,BU,@ES#,2023-04-04 12:42:00,4123.00,4125.00,4122.75,4125.00,989230,2958,,
B-@ES#-00180-s,BU,@ES#,2023-04-04 12:42:00,4123.00,4127.50,4122.75,4126.50,992407,6135,,
B-@ES#-00180-s,BU,@ES#,2023-04-04 12:42:00,4123.00,4127.50,4122.75,4125.00,994452,8180,,
B-@ES#-00180-s,BU,@ES#,2023-04-04 12:42:00,4123.00,4127.50,4122.75,4125.75,996636,10364,,
B-@ES#-00180-s,BC,@ES#,2023-04-04 12:42:00,4123.00,4127.50,4122.75,4126.75,997380,11108,,
B-@ES#-00180-s,BU,@ES#,2023-04-04 12:45:00,4126.50,4126.75,4125.75,4126.00,998656,1276,,

As you can see, I received a history bar for 2023-04-04 12:42:00 on 2023-04-04 12-39-xx mark and later received BU messages corresponding to the same bar.

The command for the above two examples in my first post are similar with the exception of the request time for the command and BeginDateTime parameter.

New IQFeed Forum » Unaligned Bars from BW Command Apr 1, 2023 03:15 PM (Total replies: 9)

We made a BW request on 02:52:00 for a 3-minute interval and update interval of 30 seconds. We received BH messages (based on historical data) uptill 02:52:00 and all prior history bars were 3-minutes apart. The problem is that after 02:52:00 marks, the next streaming bar comes at 02:54:00 which is two minutes apart from the last bar. After the bar at 02:54:00, all the streaming bars are once again 3-minutes apart. The stream is given below

B-@ES#-00180-s,BH,@ES#,2023-03-29 02:40:00,4026.75,4026.75,4026.25,4026.75,73084,391,0,
B-@ES#-00180-s,BH,@ES#,2023-03-29 02:43:00,4026.50,4027.50,4026.50,4027.00,73447,363,0,
B-@ES#-00180-s,BH,@ES#,2023-03-29 02:46:00,4027.00,4027.25,4026.25,4026.75,73754,307,0,
B-@ES#-00180-s,BH,@ES#,2023-03-29 02:49:00,4027.00,4027.25,4026.75,4026.75,74208,454,0,

B-@ES#-00180-s,BH,@ES#,2023-03-29 02:52:00,4026.75,4027.25,4026.50,4027.00,74509,301,0,
B-@ES#-00180-s,BU,@ES#,2023-03-29 02:54:00,4026.75,4027.25,4026.50,4027.25,74546,338,,

B-@ES#-00180-s,BU,@ES#,2023-03-29 02:54:00,4026.75,4027.50,4026.50,4027.25,74621,413,,
B-@ES#-00180-s,BC,@ES#,2023-03-29 02:54:00,4026.75,4027.50,4026.50,4027.50,74651,443,,
B-@ES#-00180-s,BU,@ES#,2023-03-29 02:57:00,4027.75,4027.75,4027.25,4027.25,74747,96,,
B-@ES#-00180-s,BU,@ES#,2023-03-29 02:57:00,4027.75,4027.75,4026.50,4026.75,74966,315,,
B-@ES#-00180-s,BU,@ES#,2023-03-29 02:57:00,4027.75,4027.75,4026.50,4027.00,75039,388,,
B-@ES#-00180-s,BU,@ES#,2023-03-29 02:57:00,4027.75,4027.75,4026.50,4027.75,75217,566,,
B-@ES#-00180-s,BU,@ES#,2023-03-29 02:57:00,4027.75,4028.00,4026.50,4028.00,75381,730,,
B-@ES#-00180-s,BC,@ES#,2023-03-29 02:57:00,4027.75,4028.25,4026.50,4028.25,75452,801,,


My question is if there is a way we can make sure that all history, update and closed bars are 3 minutes apart?

In another occurrence, I receive the following stream:


B-@ES#-00180-s,BH,@ES#,2023-03-29 04:26:00,4032.75,4034.50,4032.75,4034.50,113520,792,0,
B-@ES#-00180-s,BH,@ES#,2023-03-29 04:29:00,4034.25,4035.00,4034.25,4034.50,114138,618,0,
B-@ES#-00180-s,BH,@ES#,2023-03-29 04:32:00,4034.50,4036.75,4034.25,4036.75,115551,1413,0,
B-@ES#-00180-s,BH,@ES#,2023-03-29 04:35:00,4036.75,4036.75,4035.50,4035.75,115989,438,0,

B-@ES#-00180-s,BC,@ES#,2023-03-29 04:36:00,4036.75,4036.75,4035.50,4035.75,115989,438,,

B-@ES#-00180-s,BU,@ES#,2023-03-29 04:33:00,4036.00,4036.75,4036.00,4036.50,116292,303,,
B-@ES#-00180-s,BC,@ES#,2023-03-29 04:33:00,4036.00,4037.25,4036.00,4037.25,116458,469,,
B-@ES#-00180-s,BU,@ES#,2023-03-29 04:36:00,4037.25,4037.75,4037.00,4037.25,116978,520,,
B-@ES#-00180-s,BU,@ES#,2023-03-29 04:36:00,4037.25,4037.75,4036.75,4036.75,117217,759,,
B-@ES#-00180-s,BU,@ES#,2023-03-29 04:36:00,4037.25,4037.75,4036.50,4036.75,117426,968,,
B-@ES#-00180-s,BU,@ES#,2023-03-29 04:36:00,4037.25,4037.75,4036.50,4036.50,117630,1172,,
B-@ES#-00180-s,BU,@ES#,2023-03-29 04:36:00,4037.25,4037.75,4036.50,4037.00,117808,1350,,


The request was made on 04:32:00 for a 3-minute interval and update interval of 30 seconds. We received BH messages (based on historical data) uptill 04:35:00 and all prior history bars were 3-minutes apart. There are multiple problems with the stream:

  • How can IQFEED calculate the 04:35:00 history bar at 04:32:00 mark. I understand if it starts sending BU messages for the 04:35:00 bar, but a history bar means that the bar has been closed based on historical data. So, how the 04:35:00 history bar can be closed at 04:32:00 mark.

  • We received a BC close bar message for 04:36:00 (highlighted green) and later received BU (update) messages for the same bar.

  • The previously discussed problem of misaligned interval bars like 04:32, 04:33, 04:35 and 04:36 still remains. The difference between these bars should be 3 minutes.



Can anyone please clarify how can I make sure that all historical and current bars are received in order as well as the same time interval apart?


Time: Fri May 3, 2024 1:54 PM CFBB v1.2.0 9 ms.
© AderSoftware 2002-2003